Guides / Find underpayments
Guide · 6 minute read · Last checked Nov 2026How to find dental underpayments against your PPO fee schedule
Compare the allowed amount on each paid line with the fee your PPO fee schedule lists for that procedure code with that insurer. If the allowed amount is lower and nothing else on the line explains it, the gap is not a write-off: ask the insurer to reprocess the line at your fee schedule's fee.
The contractual write-off itself shows as CO-45, which X12 describes as “Charge exceeds fee schedule/maximum allowable or contracted/legislated fee arrangement.” It is right only when what's left after it equals your fee schedule's fee.
Where to find your fee schedule
- Your participation agreement, or the fee schedule the insurer sent when you joined its network. Ask provider relations for the current one in writing, with its effective date.
- In Texas, plans under Insurance Code Chapter 1451, Subchapter E must keep a website for dentists and patients that shows covered services, the percentage of allowed charges paid and, for contracting dentists, an estimated payment (§1451.205(b)–(c)).
Step by step
- Collect the fee schedule for each insurer you're in network with, by procedure code.
- Collect the payments: the insurers' electronic payment files (835s) or EOBs for the period.
- For each line, take the allowed amount (billed minus the contractual adjustment), not the paid amount: the patient's share (PR-1 deductible, PR-2 coinsurance, PR-3 co-payment) comes out after.
- Set aside lines priced by another rule: multiple-procedure reductions (CARC 59, “Processed based on multiple or concurrent procedure rules”) and alternate benefits (CARC 169, “Alternate benefit has been provided”; see alternate benefits).
- Compare: allowed below your fee schedule's fee = an underpayment. Note the gap per line.
- Group the gaps by insurer and send one reprocessing request per insurer, listing each claim, code, fee schedule fee and allowed amount.
- Watch the next payment file for the corrections, and check the same codes on new claims from that insurer.
Example (made up)
Your fee schedule lists $96.00 for D1110 with one insurer. A claim billed at $120.00 comes back: CO-45 $36.00, allowed $84.00, paid $84.00. The allowed amount is $12.00 below your fee schedule. The same happened on 40 cleanings over three months: $480.00 to ask for.
For what the other numbers on the line mean, see why the payment was less than you expected.
Questions
How do I know if a dental PPO underpaid a claim?
Look at the allowed amount on each line, not the paid amount. If the allowed amount is below the fee your PPO fee schedule lists for that procedure code, and no other adjustment explains it (such as multiple-procedure rules, CARC 59, or an alternate benefit, CARC 169), the gap is an underpayment to ask the insurer to reprocess.
Where do I find my dental PPO fee schedule?
In your participation agreement or the fee schedule the insurer sent when you joined; ask provider relations for the current one. In Texas, plans under Insurance Code Chapter 1451, Subchapter E must keep a website that shows, for contracting dentists, an estimated payment (§1451.205(b)–(c)).
Is CO-45 an underpayment?
CO-45 is the contractual write-off: X12 describes CARC 45 as "Charge exceeds fee schedule/maximum allowable or contracted/legislated fee arrangement." It is correct only when the allowed amount left after it matches your fee schedule's fee.
Let Owedex do the line-by-line check. Add your fee schedule and the insurers' payment files, and every line allowed below your fee schedule is listed with the gap and the letter to send.
Owedex accounts open to everyone at app.owedex.com once our email service is approved; until then, email demo@owedex.com for a demo.
Sources
- X12: Claim Adjustment Reason Codes
- Texas Insurance Code Chapter 1451, Subchapter E (§§1451.201–1451.209), Texas Legislature
Last checked Nov 2026. Laws and insurer pages change: open the source before you rely on it.
General information for dental billing staff, not legal advice. Plan terms, contracts and insurer rules vary: check the patient's plan, your contract and the insurer's provider manual.